NewsMarkets

Culture

David O Russell's 'Madden' Biopic Receives Mixed Reviews for Nicolas Cage's Portrayal

Critics describe David O Russell’s biopic about John Madden as a cartoonish and incoherent stunt, while some praise the eccentric performances of Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale.

9 publishers · 13 articles · first seen 17 Nov 2026 · updated 14h ago

Headline and summary written by an AI model from the linked articles; not reviewed by a person. How this was made

The odds

How the odds moved · Madden
0%50%100%13%16 Nov, 16:01 UTCnowThe Guardian US: NFL legend John Madden’s unlikely, unfiltered brilliance: ‘Coach was indeed animated’ · 20 Nov, 10:00 UTCVariety: ‘Madden’: Why Christian Bale Ranks Raiders Owner Al Davis as One of His Favorite Characters and the Jewelry He Took Home From Set · 19 Nov, 22:35 UTCThe New York Times: ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Goes Big in N.F.L. Biopic · 18 Nov, 23:00 UTCThe Guardian US: Madden review – Nicolas Cage is a cartoonish NFL legend in David O Russell’s stinker · 18 Nov, 17:35 UTCThe Hollywood Reporter: Nicolas Cage on His Approach to Playing John Madden in New Biopic: “I’m Not an Impressionist” · 18 Nov, 17:00 UTCVariety: ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Plays John Madden as the Disheveled Buddha of Football in David O. Russell’s Eccentric Stunt of a Sports Biopic · 17 Nov, 17:00 UTCThe Hollywood Reporter: ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale Go for Broke in a Cartoonish Biopic From David O. Russell That’s Strictly for Football Fanatics · 17 Nov, 17:00 UTCSI Feed: How Christian Bale Transformed Into Al Davis for ‘Madden’ · 20 Nov, 22:01 UTCNational Review: The American Genius of Madden · 20 Nov, 11:00 UTCSI Feed: Nicolas Cage Went to Extreme Lengths to Become John Madden · 19 Nov, 20:55 UTCConsequence: Madden Is a Massive Fumble: Review · 17 Nov, 17:00 UTCThe A.V. Club: A disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy · 17 Nov, 17:00 UTCIndieWire: ‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell Fumbles Again with an Unfunny and Purposeless Football Biopic · 17 Nov, 17:00 UTC

Each tick is a source publishing on this story

Price data
TimeChance of yes
now13%
19 Nov, 10:34 UTC13%
18 Nov, 21:39 UTC7%
17 Nov, 20:50 UTC8%
17 Nov, 18:00 UTC12%
17 Nov, 17:11 UTC20%
16 Nov, 16:01 UTC19%

The story so far

9 publishers have covered this in 13 articles since 17 Nov 2026. The Hollywood Reporter published first, on 17 November at 17:00 UTC. The most recent article, from SI Feed, appeared on 20 November at 22:01 UTC.

Outlets reporting it: The Hollywood Reporter (major outlet), Variety (major outlet), The Guardian US (major outlet), The New York Times (major outlet), IndieWire, The A.V. Club, Consequence, SI Feed, National Review.

One prediction market prices this story:

  • Madden — the market puts it at 13%, closing 31 Dec 2027. The market resolves to Yes if the film Madden receives a nomination for Best Makeup and Hairstyling at the 99th Academy Awards. It resolves to No if it does not receive that specific nomination. Readers often mistake general critical praise or other award nominations for the required official Academy nomination.

Odds are the market's probability that the outcome happens, updated every few minutes. They are information about what traders expect, not a forecast we make and not investment advice.

How it unfolded

Every source in the order it published, with the odds on Madden at that moment. A dash means the source published before we started tracking prices.

  1. The Hollywood Reporter‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale Go for Broke in a Cartoonish Biopic From David O. Russell That’s Strictly for Football Fanatics19%
  2. IndieWire‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell Fumbles Again with an Unfunny and Purposeless Football Biopic19%
  3. Variety‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Plays John Madden as the Disheveled Buddha of Football in David O. Russell’s Eccentric Stunt of a Sports Biopic19%
  4. The A.V. ClubA disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy19%
  5. ConsequenceMadden Is a Massive Fumble: Review19%
  6. The Hollywood ReporterNicolas Cage on His Approach to Playing John Madden in New Biopic: “I’m Not an Impressionist”8%▼11 points since the previous source
  7. The Guardian USMadden review – Nicolas Cage is a cartoonish NFL legend in David O Russell’s stinker8%
  8. The New York Times‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Goes Big in N.F.L. Biopic7%▼1 points since the previous source
  9. SI FeedNicolas Cage Went to Extreme Lengths to Become John Madden13%▲6 points since the previous source
  10. Variety‘Madden’: Why Christian Bale Ranks Raiders Owner Al Davis as One of His Favorite Characters and the Jewelry He Took Home From Set13%
  11. Show 3 later sources
    1. The Guardian USNFL legend John Madden’s unlikely, unfiltered brilliance: ‘Coach was indeed animated’13%
    2. National ReviewThe American Genius of Madden13%
    3. SI FeedHow Christian Bale Transformed Into Al Davis for ‘Madden’13%
  12. Current odds13%

Sources

Every article we clustered into this story. Headlines link to the publisher.

  1. NFL legend John Madden’s unlikely, unfiltered brilliance: ‘Coach was indeed animated’ The Guardian US ·
  2. ‘Madden’: Why Christian Bale Ranks Raiders Owner Al Davis as One of His Favorite Characters and the Jewelry He Took Home From Set Variety ·
  3. ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Goes Big in N.F.L. Biopic The New York Times ·
  4. Madden review – Nicolas Cage is a cartoonish NFL legend in David O Russell’s stinker The Guardian US ·
  5. Nicolas Cage on His Approach to Playing John Madden in New Biopic: “I’m Not an Impressionist” The Hollywood Reporter ·
  6. ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage Plays John Madden as the Disheveled Buddha of Football in David O. Russell’s Eccentric Stunt of a Sports Biopic Variety ·
Show 7 more sources
  1. ‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale Go for Broke in a Cartoonish Biopic From David O. Russell That’s Strictly for Football Fanatics The Hollywood Reporter ·
  2. How Christian Bale Transformed Into Al Davis for ‘Madden’ SI Feed
  3. The American Genius of Madden National Review
  4. Nicolas Cage Went to Extreme Lengths to Become John Madden SI Feed
  5. Madden Is a Massive Fumble: Review Consequence
  6. A disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy The A.V. Club
  7. ‘Madden’ Review: David O. Russell Fumbles Again with an Unfunny and Purposeless Football Biopic IndieWire

Related prediction markets

Linked by software because they are about the same subject. Most ask a different question from the one this story reports, so read each market's own question. How often the link is right

  • Kalshi Madden · Oscar nominees: Best Makeup and Hairstyling 13% $0 24hends 31 Dec 2027

    Does the market have this right?

    Wrong market?

Have your say

Your call. How does this end?

Free, no money involved. Calls are scored against the market's price when you make them, so backing an underdog that wins scores most. Leaderboard · Your calls

Alert me when the odds move

Email: we send a link to confirm first, and you can unsubscribe in one click. Browser notifications need no email and are turned off on the Following page. At most one alert every six hours either way. Privacy

In this story

  • Nicolas Cage
  • Christian Bale
  • David O Russell
  • John Madden
  • Al Davis
Embed this story

Paste this into any web page to show the live odds, with a link back here.